Research integrity in practice: beyond the routine

Research integrity in practice: beyond the routine

Research integrity is such a broad term. In practice, the work required day-to-day to maintain and uphold it can differ greatly from one project, journal or case to another.

Integrity checks already form part of routine manuscript handling for the hundreds of journals we support at The Editorial Hub; from plagiarism screening to checks for issues such as image manipulation, AI-generated content and potential papermill activity. Alongside this day-to-day work, our dedicated research integrity team undertakes more detailed project and investigative work, which is the main focus of this article.

Our recent research integrity project work has covered a wide range of areas; including detailed journal audits and investigations into suspicious user accounts, as well as editorial board checks, reviewer-quality audits, citation and reference reviews, and authorship-change investigations.

Much of this work involves looking beyond the issue that first prompted a closer look. What appears initially to concern one manuscript, reviewer, editor or account can sometimes form part of a wider pattern of activity warranting investigation.

Following the evidence through the editorial process

A journal audit is a good example of how detailed this can become.

In audits undertaken by our team, we have looked at publication history, author verification, geographic distribution and email patterns, CRediT information, ORCID records, plagiarism, reviewer suitability and the eventual editorial decision. The resulting report can also trace editor assignments, peer-review history and decision history from submission through to final decision.

No single piece of information necessarily tells the story. The value comes from being able to examine the different elements together and identify areas that warrant closer attention.

The same applies to reviewer activity. Our work has included reviewing peer-review reports across revisions to identify instances where reviewers have recommended citations to their own work or repeatedly recommended an author’s work, as well as checking the quality and relevance of reviews and identifying empty reviews.

We’ve also undertaken reference reviews to check validity, monitor self-citation and flag hallucinated references, and investigated authorship changes from submission through revision and publication, including the reasons and evidence provided for those changes.

Sometimes the manuscript isn’t the starting point

Research integrity work isn’t limited to examining content.

Our team also carries out background checks on prospective editorial board members and guest editors. Depending on the requirements of the client, these can include checks of institutional affiliation, publication and editorial history, retractions, professional experience and other relevant information, resulting in a report for the publisher to consider.

Another strand of our work involves users who have already been identified by a client’s ethics team as potentially concerning. As part of that work, we apply the appropriate flags or system-access changes specified by the publisher and search for potentially linked accounts using alternative names or email addresses. Possible matches are then returned to the ethics team for further review.

That distinction matters. Identifying something potentially suspicious isn’t the same as determining that misconduct has occurred. Our role is to investigate the concern, assess and document the available evidence and, where appropriate, make appropriate recommendations based on what we find.

Research integrity can be preventative as well as investigative

A lot of the work above also illustrates why research integrity doesn’t have to start after a serious problem has been identified.

Checking prospective editors and guest editors, monitoring reviewer activity, examining unusual account relationships or reviewing references and authorship changes can all form part of the wider editorial process.

Our current research integrity services therefore extend across submitted and published manuscripts, editor and reviewer due diligence, suspicious-user monitoring, investigations and post-publication support, as well as work on policies, SOPs and editorial processes.

Our practical experience shows how preventative and investigative work can sit alongside one another. Some activity responds to an existing concern; elsewhere, the focus is on identifying and examining risks earlier or strengthening the processes around them.

And what about what’s already been published?

Research integrity questions don’t necessarily end at publication either.

Our recent work has included checks on published articles, including analysing peer-review activity for potential integrity concerns, as well as citation, reference and authorship reviews.

Our post-publication work also includes investigating suspicious accounts and articles, account linking and flagging, and reporting findings back to publisher teams. We are also extending this work into published archive review, investigating concerns that have been flagged and leading the appropriate follow-up where required.

This is an area we think is worth exploring separately in a later post. Strengthening the checks applied to content moving through today’s editorial workflows is one challenge; deciding how to approach potential concerns within an existing body of published research is another.

Where do tools fit?

Technology is part of this work too, but we think it is important to be specific about its role rather than simply saying that AI or automation will solve research-integrity problems.

Our team has hands-on experience with tools covering plagiarism detection, AI-generated or manipulated text, image manipulation and potential paper-mill activity. In our approach, outputs from tools are reviewed and interpreted by trained staff and used to support decision-making rather than make the decision itself.

There is much more to say about what using these tools looks like in practice, including where they are useful, where they need further investigation and what they mean for editorial workflows. We’ll come back to that in a separate post, too.

Connecting research integrity with editorial operations

One of the advantages of combining specialist research integrity expertise with day-to-day editorial office management is the view it gives across different parts of the publishing process.

Jenny Bright, our Research Integrity Manager, leads our specialist research integrity expertise, supported by a dedicated team working on research integrity projects. Alongside this dedicated project work, that expertise feeds into our wider operations. Across the journals and projects we support, our Managing Editors and Editorial Assistants can identify and document potential concerns through their day-to-day work, drawing on specialist guidance where something needs closer examination or escalation.

That can help provide context for activity that might otherwise be considered in isolation: a concern raised during manuscript handling, an unusual reviewer pattern, questions around an account or affiliation, or something identified through a wider audit. Specialist research integrity expertise doesn’t sit apart from editorial operations; it works alongside them.

A practical view of research integrity

Perhaps the clearest lesson from the range of work our team is doing is the importance of context. A concern rarely exists entirely in isolation, and understanding what sits around it can be just as important as identifying the initial issue.

That might mean investigating one suspicious account and then looking for connections with others. It might mean examining a peer-review report, checking a reference list, carrying out due diligence on a potential editor, or tracing the complete editorial history of a manuscript.

Sometimes the work is preventative. Sometimes it responds to an existing concern. And sometimes it means going back to content that has already been published.

What matters is being able to bring those different pieces of evidence together, understand them in their editorial context, and recognise when something warrants further investigation or escalation.

For The Editorial Hub, that practical, connected approach is increasingly an important part of how we support publishers with research integrity and publishing ethics.

Proud to Support ALPSP as Silver Sponsor at the 2026 Annual Conference

We’re delighted to share that The Editorial Hub is a Silver Sponsor of the ALPSP Annual Conference and Awards 2026, taking place from 9-11 September in Manchester.

The ALPSP Annual Conference is a cornerstone event for scholarly and professional publishing, bringing together publishers, societies, service providers and industry partners from across the global community. As long‑standing supporters of collaboration, integrity and innovation in editorial workflows, becoming a Silver Sponsor felt like a natural step for us.

ALPSP plays an important role in strengthening and advocating for not‑for‑profit scholarly publishing, while bringing together a broad international community of society, university and commercial publishers, alongside the service providers that support them. With more than 320 member organisations across 35 countries, the conference offers a rare opportunity to step back from day‑to‑day operations and engage in meaningful conversations about what publishing needs next – whether that’s navigating technological change, improving peer review health, or responding to evolving community expectations.

At The Editorial Hub, we work closely with journals and publishers to support robust, scalable editorial and peer review processes. Our presence at ALPSP reflects our commitment not just to the tools and systems that underpin publishing, but to the people, partnerships and shared standards that make the ecosystem work.

As Silver Sponsor, we’re pleased to be supporting an event that values thoughtful discussion, practical insight and collective progress across the industry. We’re particularly looking forward to the conversations that emerge when publishers, societies and service providers come together to reflect honestly on shared challenges – and to explore what genuinely sustainable solutions look like.

If you’re attending the conference in Manchester this September, we’d love to see you there and connect in person. Whether you’re thinking about editorial workflow efficiency, peer review resilience or future‑proofing journal operations, we always welcome the chance to exchange ideas and learn from others in the community. And if you’d like to start a conversation ahead of the conference, you’re very welcome to get in touch at any time – we’re always happy to talk through editorial challenges, share perspectives, or simply compare notes on what’s changing across the scholarly publishing landscape.

We’re delighted to continue supporting ALPSP and to be an active part of what promises to be an engaging and thought‑provoking conference.

Celebrating women‑led businesses through International Women’s Day

As part of cake.com’s Give to Gain initiative for International Women’s Day, our co‑founders and directors, Stephanie and Naomi, were invited to take part in a conversation celebrating women leaders and the realities of building businesses with purpose.

Founded in 2014 by Steph and Naomi — who still own and manage the company today — The Editorial Hub has grown from a two‑person operation into a globally recognised editorial services provider, supporting around 300 journals and publishing projects each year. Throughout that growth, our values have remained constant.

We are proudly independent and predominantly women‑led, with women making up our entire senior management team and around 90% of our freelance team. Central to our success is a flexible, fully remote working model that has been in place since the very beginning — long before flexible work became mainstream.

This approach enables our team to work in ways that suit their lives and responsibilities, whether that means a few hours a week or full‑time engagement, allowing us to attract and retain the best talent. For our clients, it means quality of service, reliability, continuity and the ability to scale quickly to meet new launches, tight deadlines or last‑minute cover — 52 weeks a year.

Participating in cake.com’s Give to Gain initiative offered a valuable opportunity to reflect on how women‑led businesses can challenge traditional models of work, while building organisations that are resilient, inclusive and built to last.

🎥 View the conversation here

While International Women’s Day provides an important moment to spotlight women founders and leaders, our commitment to supporting people‑centred publishing — and delivering high‑quality editorial services at scale — continues every day.

If you’d like to find out more about our services, or would be interested in joining our team, we’d love to hear from you.

What Does a Journal Administrator Actually Do?

Managing Editors, Administrators, Journal Staff, Editorial Assistants – whatever you want to call us, we play an integral role in getting your manuscript through peer review. But you may wonder what it is we actually do.

You see, we Managing Editors wear many hats. The honest answer to What It Is We Do is really that we do whatever our particular editor, publisher, and journal workflow needs us to do. But there are some tasks that are common for most of us, so here’s a quick TEH Blog rundown.

System support

Most journals these days make use of an online submission system. These systems are absolutely invaluable to the smooth running of a busy global journal (more on that here), but we are all too aware that they can be confusing and frustrating if you aren’t used to using them.

Your friendly neighbourhood Managing Editors are therefore on hand to answer any questions, resolve any upload problems, and generally support authors, reviewers, and editors in successfully navigating their way through all the buttons, links, and questions.

Administrator checks

Once you’ve submitted your manuscript (whether you needed our help do to so or not), the first thing that will happen is that somebody will check it over to make sure that nothing is missing, and that it’s suitable for peer review. And just who might that “somebody” be? You’ve guessed it: the Managing Editor.

The checks we’re asked to perform varies journal to journal. Sometimes it is literally a case of making sure the manuscript text hasn’t been missed out by mistake, and sometimes it’s an in-depth analysis of your referencing format. Whatever the checks are, it’ll be us who gets in touch to guide you through making any changes, and it’s us who will approve it for review.

Status updates

It might feel like you submitted your manuscript aaaages ago and the status in your author centre has been saying the same thing for a really long time… When the waiting game finally gets too much and you fire off an email to the journal’s Editorial Office, it’s one of us who will respond to give you some idea of what’s happening.

Unfortunately delays do happen – editors and reviewers are, after all, busy people and inevitably deadlines get missed periodically – but we are always working to keep them to a minimum, and are always happy to give you an update. You can find out more about what goes on behind the scenes here.

Point of contact

It’s not just status updates for authors that we handle, however. Been asked to review a paper but need an extension on the deadline? Drop us an email. Need to return your conflict of interest form for your accepted paper? Send it over to us. Somehow wound up with multiple accounts on the submission system that are causing you login problems? We can help with that, too.

In fact, pretty much anything you need as an author, reviewer or editor can be sent to us. If we’re unable to help you ourselves then we will know who to forward the message on to. We Managing Editors are your one-stop shop for all your peer review needs.

Reporting

One of the many benefits of peer review being handled through a submission system is that we can gather data on number of submissions, how many of those get accepted, and even where in the world the research originated from.

When you’re down in the trenches working away at getting the papers assigned to you through peer review it’s not always easy to see the bigger picture, so being able to get actual figures on how many submissions are coming into your journal (and, crucially, how that compares to how many submissions you’ve received in previous years) is absolutely invaluable.

And it’s we Managing Editors who can not only get you this data, but organise it into a report that makes sense of it all.

What’s it Like to Work for The Editorial Hub?

We talk a lot on this blog about the work we do at The Editorial Hub, but what’s it like to work for The Editorial Hub? We caught up with some of the team to find out.

 

Our team all work remotely

In these post-pandemic times, most of the corporate workforce now have some experience of working from home; but we’ve been doing it for years! So what are the benefits?

“I love the flexibility of working with TEH. I’ve got two young children and this role allows me to work around them. I’m finding it fits much better with family life and I can do the school pick-up every day.” Lindsay

“The work-life balance I get from working with The Editorial Hub works really well for me. I have the freedom to pursue my interests without having to compromise on my working hours.” Debs

 

Our team still feels like a team

Working from home can be very isolating, but we make sure that every single person who works with us is supported, heard, and connected. We have various online chats set up so if anyone has a problem, a question, or even just some amusing anecdotes they’re itching to share, they can do so and get an immediate response.

“The team are great, fun and supportive – always there if you need help/guidance with something you are unsure of.” Anouska

“If you log in to find one of your submission sites is misbehaving, a quick message on the chat will confirm you’re not alone, and you can commiserate as a group until the issue’s resolved! It’s also lovely to have 40+ people wish you a happy birthday every year.” Debs

 

Our team is a wonderful resource

Not only are our team a lovely bunch of people, they really know their stuff. With a collective publishing knowledge adding up to centuries of experience, no problem is unsurmountable for our Hive Mind – which any member of the team can access at any time by typing a quick message.

“Working with a pool of such talented people you can learn something new every day, and you know you have the back up of this wonderful pool of knowledge if you need it!” Penny

 

Want to join our wonderful team?

We pride ourselves on providing the best-possible service to our clients and customers. And no two days are the same!

“I am learning new skills along the way and each journal has its own way of operating, so the work is varied.” Anouska

“I love the flexibility provided at The Editorial Hub and find my role very rewarding and interesting. Everyone is so wonderful and supportive. A great team, a credit to you all.” Sharon

If you’re an experienced publishing professional looking to escape the 9-5 and the above sounds like a great career move, then we’d love to talk to you. Get in touch with us to find out more!

 

London Book Fair

The 2023 London Book Fair is coming up next week and it is always a highlight in The Editorial Hub directors’ diaries. We caught up with Naomi Conneely and Stephanie Sacharov to find out why.

 

What are you looking forward to doing at this year’s fair?

We’re planning on attending more of the seminars that appeal to us and our business. It is always a good way to see what others are doing, which services are provided, and what new technologies and advancements have been made. It’s a great opportunity to meet up with publishing colleagues, so if you see us do say hello!

 

How was last year’s London Book Fair?

It was great to get back to a normal event after recent years with no face-to-face meetings. We attended on the opening day and it was busy, but possibly not as busy as on previous occasions. We made several contacts with new publishers as well as meeting up with existing clients and business partners.

 

You’ve been to the London Book Fair several times – what keeps drawing you back?

The LBF is a very relaxed event and most publishers are situated in the same area. It’s just a great opportunity to catch up with old friends and make new ones. The ALPSP stand is in a central point within the academic publishing area and always draws a large crowd. It’s a brilliant opportunity to see publishing colleagues in a dedicated area.

 

Had last year’s fair changed since pre-pandemic times?

It did feel completely normal last year. Perhaps there was a little more space in the aisles than in previous years, but generally it felt the same.

 

How does the London Book Fair compare to other industry conferences and events?

It is a completely different vibe to other meetings, being a fair as opposed to a conference. There are more sales and marketing personnel that attend the LBF so we find it important to contact people in advance to make appointments to meet when we are all there.

 

What else is on your conference schedule for 2023?

We’ll be at the SSP Regional Meetup in Bristol later this month, as well as the ALPSP annual conference in Manchester in September, so we’re looking forward to catching up with fellow colleagues there. We also regularly attend webinars that are available via ALPSP, COPE, SSP, ISMTE and the submission site providers (e.g. Aries and Clarivate); and of course we are always available at the end of a phone, via email, and to meet up in person with clients. Please get in touch if you’d like a chat!