Research integrity in practice: beyond the routine

Research integrity in practice: beyond the routine

Research integrity is such a broad term. In practice, the work required day-to-day to maintain and uphold it can differ greatly from one project, journal or case to another.

Integrity checks already form part of routine manuscript handling for the hundreds of journals we support at The Editorial Hub; from plagiarism screening to checks for issues such as image manipulation, AI-generated content and potential papermill activity. Alongside this day-to-day work, our dedicated research integrity team undertakes more detailed project and investigative work, which is the main focus of this article.

Our recent research integrity project work has covered a wide range of areas; including detailed journal audits and investigations into suspicious user accounts, as well as editorial board checks, reviewer-quality audits, citation and reference reviews, and authorship-change investigations.

Much of this work involves looking beyond the issue that first prompted a closer look. What appears initially to concern one manuscript, reviewer, editor or account can sometimes form part of a wider pattern of activity warranting investigation.

Following the evidence through the editorial process

A journal audit is a good example of how detailed this can become.

In audits undertaken by our team, we have looked at publication history, author verification, geographic distribution and email patterns, CRediT information, ORCID records, plagiarism, reviewer suitability and the eventual editorial decision. The resulting report can also trace editor assignments, peer-review history and decision history from submission through to final decision.

No single piece of information necessarily tells the story. The value comes from being able to examine the different elements together and identify areas that warrant closer attention.

The same applies to reviewer activity. Our work has included reviewing peer-review reports across revisions to identify instances where reviewers have recommended citations to their own work or repeatedly recommended an author’s work, as well as checking the quality and relevance of reviews and identifying empty reviews.

We’ve also undertaken reference reviews to check validity, monitor self-citation and flag hallucinated references, and investigated authorship changes from submission through revision and publication, including the reasons and evidence provided for those changes.

Sometimes the manuscript isn’t the starting point

Research integrity work isn’t limited to examining content.

Our team also carries out background checks on prospective editorial board members and guest editors. Depending on the requirements of the client, these can include checks of institutional affiliation, publication and editorial history, retractions, professional experience and other relevant information, resulting in a report for the publisher to consider.

Another strand of our work involves users who have already been identified by a client’s ethics team as potentially concerning. As part of that work, we apply the appropriate flags or system-access changes specified by the publisher and search for potentially linked accounts using alternative names or email addresses. Possible matches are then returned to the ethics team for further review.

That distinction matters. Identifying something potentially suspicious isn’t the same as determining that misconduct has occurred. Our role is to investigate the concern, assess and document the available evidence and, where appropriate, make appropriate recommendations based on what we find.

Research integrity can be preventative as well as investigative

A lot of the work above also illustrates why research integrity doesn’t have to start after a serious problem has been identified.

Checking prospective editors and guest editors, monitoring reviewer activity, examining unusual account relationships or reviewing references and authorship changes can all form part of the wider editorial process.

Our current research integrity services therefore extend across submitted and published manuscripts, editor and reviewer due diligence, suspicious-user monitoring, investigations and post-publication support, as well as work on policies, SOPs and editorial processes.

Our practical experience shows how preventative and investigative work can sit alongside one another. Some activity responds to an existing concern; elsewhere, the focus is on identifying and examining risks earlier or strengthening the processes around them.

And what about what’s already been published?

Research integrity questions don’t necessarily end at publication either.

Our recent work has included checks on published articles, including analysing peer-review activity for potential integrity concerns, as well as citation, reference and authorship reviews.

Our post-publication work also includes investigating suspicious accounts and articles, account linking and flagging, and reporting findings back to publisher teams. We are also extending this work into published archive review, investigating concerns that have been flagged and leading the appropriate follow-up where required.

This is an area we think is worth exploring separately in a later post. Strengthening the checks applied to content moving through today’s editorial workflows is one challenge; deciding how to approach potential concerns within an existing body of published research is another.

Where do tools fit?

Technology is part of this work too, but we think it is important to be specific about its role rather than simply saying that AI or automation will solve research-integrity problems.

Our team has hands-on experience with tools covering plagiarism detection, AI-generated or manipulated text, image manipulation and potential paper-mill activity. In our approach, outputs from tools are reviewed and interpreted by trained staff and used to support decision-making rather than make the decision itself.

There is much more to say about what using these tools looks like in practice, including where they are useful, where they need further investigation and what they mean for editorial workflows. We’ll come back to that in a separate post, too.

Connecting research integrity with editorial operations

One of the advantages of combining specialist research integrity expertise with day-to-day editorial office management is the view it gives across different parts of the publishing process.

Jenny Bright, our Research Integrity Manager, leads our specialist research integrity expertise, supported by a dedicated team working on research integrity projects. Alongside this dedicated project work, that expertise feeds into our wider operations. Across the journals and projects we support, our Managing Editors and Editorial Assistants can identify and document potential concerns through their day-to-day work, drawing on specialist guidance where something needs closer examination or escalation.

That can help provide context for activity that might otherwise be considered in isolation: a concern raised during manuscript handling, an unusual reviewer pattern, questions around an account or affiliation, or something identified through a wider audit. Specialist research integrity expertise doesn’t sit apart from editorial operations; it works alongside them.

A practical view of research integrity

Perhaps the clearest lesson from the range of work our team is doing is the importance of context. A concern rarely exists entirely in isolation, and understanding what sits around it can be just as important as identifying the initial issue.

That might mean investigating one suspicious account and then looking for connections with others. It might mean examining a peer-review report, checking a reference list, carrying out due diligence on a potential editor, or tracing the complete editorial history of a manuscript.

Sometimes the work is preventative. Sometimes it responds to an existing concern. And sometimes it means going back to content that has already been published.

What matters is being able to bring those different pieces of evidence together, understand them in their editorial context, and recognise when something warrants further investigation or escalation.

For The Editorial Hub, that practical, connected approach is increasingly an important part of how we support publishers with research integrity and publishing ethics.

Beyond faster horses at ALPSP 2026

The ALPSP 2026 conference was full of ideas for changing scholarly publishing. For smaller societies, the harder question was how to create enough capacity to act on them.

The conference brought three days of discussion about an industry facing change on almost every front. AI was reshaping discovery, research practice and editorial workflows. Research integrity threats were becoming more sophisticated. Reviewer recruitment was getting harder. Global author and reviewer communities were changing. Metadata and machine readability were moving from technical concerns to strategic ones. Universities were under financial pressure. And throughout the programme, speakers offered tools, partnerships, new workflows and new ways of thinking that might help.

But beneath many of those conversations sat a more basic constraint.

Do publishers actually have the capacity to make the changes they already know they need to make?

For smaller societies in particular, that may be one of the most important questions facing scholarly publishing.

More work is entering the system

The pressure is not imaginary.

In the Industry Updates session, David Nygren of Silverchair presented data from ScholarOne showing submissions in 2026 running 33% above the equivalent point in 2025, after 16% growth across 2025 itself (though there are sensible questions to be asked about how 1 unit of submission is being defined here). The same presentation reported 2.5 desk rejections for every accepted manuscript, a 47% increase since 2022, while it now takes roughly twice as many invitations to secure a reviewer as it did eight years ago. Despite sustained efforts to make publication faster, time to acceptance and publication had risen 21% over the same period. This is not just straightforward growth – acceptances are not growing at the same rate – it is operational drag.

At the same time, entirely new categories of work are arriving.

The Zero Click session explored what publishers may need to do as researchers increasingly discover and consume scholarship through AI interfaces rather than publisher platforms: richer metadata, machine-readable content, better attribution, new usage measures and changes to the way content itself is structured. Better definition of lay person summaries was discussed as a potentially valuable addition to metadata quality. Where did the panellists think this task should live within the publishing workflow? I’ll give you three guesses, but you won’t need two of them.

Research integrity is creating another expanding workload. Liz Allen described a fragmented ecosystem in which smaller organisations may lack dedicated integrity staff or even an obvious person with the time and expertise to take ownership of emerging issues.

None of these problems can simply be ignored. But every response competes for the same finite resource: experienced people.

The capacity catch-22

That became particularly clear in Lean Editorial: Doing More with Less Across Peer Review and Editorial Operations, a session proposed by The Editorial Hub and chaired by our Office & Business Development Manager, Kate Pearson.

The panel brought together Kimberly Bayley-Tweed of the Biochemical Society/Portland Press, Katherine Brown of The Company of Biologists and Dustin Smith of Hum. The aim was deliberately to focus on the operational reality of smaller society publishers, whose experience can look very different from that of organisations running hundreds or thousands of journals.

The session was intended to explore how lean teams could use systems, partners, skills and emerging technologies more effectively, but what emerged was something more uncomfortable: the organisations with the greatest need to redesign their workflows are often the organisations with the least spare capacity to do so.

A workflow review sounds sensible. So does evaluating a new integrity tool, improving reviewer selection, redesigning triage, introducing automation or developing better reporting. But none of those things happens by magic.

Someone has to understand the problem, map the current process, gather requirements, research the market, send emails, book meetings, sit through demonstrations, compare suppliers, build a business case, negotiate, pilot, test, calibrate, write playbooks, train colleagues, establish governance, manage exceptions and monitor whether the change actually worked.

The work that could create future capacity consumes capacity today.

That tension came through vividly in the session. Katherine Brown captured the problem with a deceptively simple image: the submission system of 20 years ago as a basic car, and today’s system as an increasingly elaborate vehicle carrying identifiers, integrity checks, data requirements, accessibility, OA rules, transfers and more. None of those additions is necessarily unreasonable in isolation. Together, they show how easily a workflow can become something nobody would ever have designed from scratch.

Another slide borrowed the familiar distracted-boyfriend meme to show organisations simultaneously committed to their existing workflow and continually tempted by the next shiny new tool. The difficulty is no longer simply finding a tool. As Katherine Brown’s slide made clear, publishers are now confronted by an expanding market of integrity, workflow and AI products, all competing for attention while the existing operation still has to run.

Choosing well means understanding not only what a product can do, but what problem it should solve, where it belongs in the workflow, who should operate it, what it costs to implement and govern, and what work it genuinely removes rather than relocates.

The number of people audibly laughing and taking pictures of these slides spoke to how recognisable and relatable an experience this was for the gathered audience. Conversations afterwards made clear that the problem extended well beyond the organisations on stage.

Don’t just build faster horses

Another conference session offered a useful way to think about the answer.

In Beyond Publishing: Lessons From the Outside, Jennifer Schivas of 67 Bricks returned to the familiar “faster horses” innovation problem. The point of the story is not that customers are incapable of knowing what they need. It is that if you ask only how to improve the existing solution you get incremental improvement, not disruptive innovation.

It is a useful reminder for editorial technology, where the conversation can quickly become tool-led.

The obvious question is: Which tool should we get?

But perhaps the better place to start is: Why are we doing this work at all? Why does it happen at this point? Why does this person do it? Which part requires expertise, and which part simply exists because the workflow evolved that way?

Amy Jones of Emerald made a related point using IKEA’s deployment of AI for routine customer queries. The interesting bit was not simply the automation – IKEA used the capacity it released to retrain people into higher-value work.

The useful lesson is not that every routine task should be automated. It is that any time saved needs somewhere better to go.

For smaller publishers, however, even asking those questions properly requires time.

And the tools market does not make matters easier. Conversations throughout the conference reinforced that many publishers know they need to modernise but feel overwhelmed by the scale of the market and the effort required to distinguish genuinely useful products from superficially similar propositions.

A tool is not a strategy. Nor is it a silver bullet. A very good product can still deliver very little if it is badly placed in the workflow, poorly calibrated, weakly governed or inadequately supported.

Protect human judgement

ALPSP also offered a clearer picture of where technology may create the most useful capacity.

Natalie Khalil of Reviewer3 described peer review as containing both objective verification and subjective scientific judgement. In benchmarking more than 145,000 review comments, her team found that humans concentrated more heavily on areas such as contribution and clarity, while automation could support technical checks and pre-review triage. That is a more useful way to approach this complex issue than trying to treat peer review as one single process that can either be automated or not.

The research integrity session told a similar story as Kim Eggleton described IOP Publishing’s use of the STM Integrity Hub duplicate-submission checker as a simple intervention that can remove significant manual effort. Hylke Koers explained how the Hub now brings together more than 50 publishers, collectively scanning over 300,000 submitted manuscripts each month and sharing intelligence that no individual publisher could realistically reproduce alone.

But integrity is also a moving target. IOP’s work on detecting identical reviewer reports is a useful reminder that today’s signal may not remain tomorrow’s signal. If obvious template-style similarities become less common, is that because manipulation has reduced, or because generative AI makes unique, plausible-looking reports easier to produce?

That is a question, not a conclusion. But it illustrates why research integrity cannot be “implemented” once and considered finished. Detection, policy and workflows all have to evolve.

Creating capacity to change

There is another capacity issue that deserves more attention: small publishing teams are often exceptionally committed. That commitment can conceal a structural problem if essential work is sustained partly through discretionary effort, extra attention and goodwill.

How resilient is a workflow if it only works because people continually stretch to absorb one more integrity check, one more reporting requirement, one more tool, one more author expectation? That is not simply a wellbeing question, it is an operational-risk question.

For societies facing this reality, the useful question may not be “should we outsource?” or “which technology should we buy?” but “what kind of capacity are we actually missing?”

From our work with societies and small press editorial teams, that capacity gap tends to show up in two ways. The first is the capacity to design the future operation: to understand the workflow, define requirements, assess the tools market, compare options, pilot changes, document decisions and put governance around whatever is introduced.

The second is the capacity to keep the current operation running while that work happens. Sometimes that means targeted support with editorial office work, desk editing, reviewer selection or integrity checks, so internal teams have enough room to step back from business as usual and make change properly.

Because The Editorial Hub is technology-agnostic, the starting point does not need to be a particular platform or product. It can be the problem itself.

By the final conference wrap-up session, our Lean Editorial session had been highlighted as one of the sessions that best captured the need to balance efficiency with human oversight. Tasha Mellins-Cohen also challenged the industry to look again at entrenched workflows and the amount of work continually pushed onto authors and reviewers – that feels like the right challenge to take away from ALPSP 2026.

As an industry, journals publishing is not short of ideas for change.

The harder question is whether we are creating enough room to implement them well.

AI Use in Academic Publishing: A Signal of Need, Not Necessarily Misconduct

Generative AI has quickly become part of the academic publishing landscape. For us, this creates a difficult challenge: how should journals respond when authors use AI to support manuscript preparation?

A recent article by Brendal Aformeziem on the LSE Impact Blog argues that we should be careful not to assume bad intentions when AI is detected in a submission. Instead, growing evidence suggests that many researchers are turning to AI because they face structural disadvantages that the publishing system has not yet resolved.

The researchers most likely to use AI are often those who need the most support. Studies cited in the article show that adoption is highest among authors from non-English-speaking countries, early-career researchers and scholars at less well-resourced institutions. For these authors, AI tools can help overcome the additional burden of writing for journals that operate primarily in English.

Importantly, the evidence suggests that AI is not removing the barriers faced by non-native English-speaking researchers. Research analysing nearly 80,000 peer reviews at ICLR found that biases linked to language and author background persisted after the arrival of ChatGPT. In some cases, reviewers have simply shifted their attention to language patterns they associate with AI-generated text, creating new forms of suspicion rather than reducing existing prejudice.

This has important implications for editorial teams. The presence of AI-generated phrasing should not automatically be treated as evidence of misconduct or an attempt to deceive. For many authors, AI is functioning as an accessibility and language-support tool rather than a shortcut to avoid scholarly work.

While many journals now require authors to declare AI use, disclosure rates remain much lower than estimated usage rates. Researchers may be reluctant to disclose because they fear stigma, negative judgement or what some scholars describe as “AI shaming”. These concerns may be particularly acute for authors working in under-resourced environments who lack access to institutional guidance and support.

For Managing Editors, this points to a need for nuance. Editorial policies should distinguish between acceptable language assistance and inappropriate uses of AI. Equally important, editorial staff should avoid treating AI detection as a proxy for author quality, integrity or competence. AI use alone tells us very little about the rigour, originality or validity of the underlying research.

As journals develop policies and workflows around AI, empathy and context will be essential. Rather than asking, “Why did this author use AI?”, editorial teams may be better served by asking, “What challenge was this author trying to overcome?” By approaching AI use as a potential signal of need rather than automatically viewing it as a signal of misconduct, journals can support both research integrity and greater inclusion in scholarly publishing. While journal AI policies are often set at an organisational level and may be outside the control of editorial staff, editorial assistants and managing editors can still play an important role by approaching suspected AI use with an open mind, recognising that for many authors these tools may represent a response to linguistic, institutional or resource-related barriers rather than an attempt to circumvent scholarly standards.

References

Aformeziem, B. (2026). AI promised to democratise academic publishing – the evidence says otherwise. LSE Impact Blog, London School of Economics and Political Science, 23 June 2026. Available at: LSE Impact Blog article [blogs.lse.ac.uk]

Lepp, H. and Smith, D.S. (2025).“You Cannot Sound Like GPT”: Signs of language discrimination and resistance in computer science publishing. Proceedings of the ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency (FAccT ’25). Available via arXiv: View paper

Y. He, & Y. Bu, Academic journals’ AI policies fail to curb the surge in AI-assisted academic writing, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 123 (9) e2526734123, https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2526734123 (2026).

Lean Editorial: Doing More with Less Across Peer Review and Editorial Operations

Lean editorial is not about doing the same work with fewer people

Every new expectation in scholarly publishing lands somewhere in an editorial workflow.

A manuscript arrives, but it no longer needs only careful handling, reviewer invitations and a clear decision. It may also trigger metadata validation, research integrity screening, open-science questions, author identity verification, funder-compliance checks, data-policy requirements, reviewer-availability challenges and the everyday work of keeping authors, editors and reviewers properly informed.

None of these expectations is unreasonable. Most reflect priorities that authors, readers and journal communities genuinely value: trust, transparency, rigour, speed, fairness and a better experience for the people who give their time to scholarly communication. But each expectation creates operational work. It needs to be sequenced, owned, recorded, checked, escalated or explained.

That is why “lean editorial” is such an important phrase to handle carefully.

Used badly, it can become a euphemism for asking stretched teams to absorb more work with fewer people. Used well, it means something much more useful: designing editorial operations so that scarce human attention, existing systems, specialist partners and new tools are used where they genuinely add value.

The case for leaner editorial redesign is becoming hard to ignore. Hanson et al.’s 2024 paper, “The strain on scientific publishing,” argues that article output has grown far faster than the human capacity required to write, review and edit it. That pressure is not abstract. It shows up in delayed decisions, overdue editor tasks, declining reviewers, increased manuscript status enquiries, and increasing reliance on workarounds that were never designed to become permanent infrastructure.

Reviewer pressure makes the point particularly clearly. Routledge and Pariente, writing in PLOS Biology in 2025, describe a system in which invitations increasingly outweigh researcher capacity to complete reviews. Recent journal-level data from Morley et al. in PRiMER gives that pressure a tangible form: in one journal, reviewer invitation acceptance peaked at just over 56% in 2020, then fell to around 36% in 2024, with completion rates also declining. Inviting ten reviewers where three might once have been enough may be necessary in the short term. It is not, on its own, a strategy.

A leaner approach asks a different set of questions. Which manuscripts should reach external peer review at all? Which checks should happen earlier, before reviewer time is spent? Where can stronger pre-review editorial assessment, clearer scope control or refreshed reviewer records reduce avoidable chasing and repeated invitation rounds? Where are editors being asked to solve operational problems that could be handled through better workflow design or additional support?

Open science and transparency expectations add another layer. Howard et al.’s account of open science at Clinical Psychological Science is useful because it shows that transparency is not simply a policy preference; it can require new roles, checks and processes. Funder and open-access compliance create similar operational demands. Tools such as Jisc’s Open Policy Finder exist because policy requirements are complex enough to need structured navigation, while Jisc’s UKRI guidance reminds publishers that compliant routes should be easier for authors to understand and use. Reducing friction is not a soft service aim; it is part of making policy workable.

Research integrity has followed a similar path. Paper mills, systematic manipulation, duplicate submissions, image concerns and inappropriate AI use are no longer occasional exceptions that can be handled entirely outside the workflow. STM Integrity Hub and United2Act both show how much work is now going into practical tools, guidance and implementation support for integrity challenges that affect the whole sector.

AI-enabled workflow and integrity tools are also now part of editorial reality, not a future possibility. The practical question is how they are governed, where they add value, and where human judgement must remain explicit. The 2026 SSP Pulse Check suggests a community experimenting with AI while worrying, rightly, about ethics, privacy, quality and capacity. UKRIO’s 2025 guidance similarly frames AI as an integrity issue touching legal compliance, ethics, the research record, dissemination and critical thinking. In editorial terms, tools can help teams see more, sooner: patterns, missing information, possible manipulation, workflow risk. But outputs still have to be interpreted. Poorly placed automation creates friction. Well-governed automation creates capacity.

This is where society publishers and smaller teams have an important perspective to offer. Research Consulting’s 2025 white paper on the future of society publishing found that most societies still see publishing as central to their mission, even while many face declining revenues and pressure to adapt. Smaller publishers may lack the scale of larger commercial houses, but they are often closer to their communities, more alert to disciplinary context and more conscious of the trust they hold.

That is the thinking behind Lean Editorial: Doing More with Less Across Peer Review and Editorial Operations, taking place at the ALPSP Conference 2026 on Thursday 10 September, 11:20–12:05, in Deansgate Suite 3. Chaired by Kate Pearson of The Editorial Hub, a Silver Sponsor of ALPSP Conference 2026, the panel brings together Kimberly Bayley-Tweed, Publishing Operations Manager at Biochemical Society / Portland Press; Katherine Brown, Publishing Director at The Company of Biologists; and Dustin Smith, Co-founder and CEO of Hum to explore these questions in practical terms.

The discussion will stay close to the practical realities of editorial work: how teams evolve workflows, build capability, use vendors and tools selectively, manage integrity and open-science expectations, and decide where human judgement is essential.

That is the real promise of lean editorial: not doing everything faster, nor asking teams to stretch indefinitely, but making better operational choices so that journals can maintain rigour, protect author and reviewer experience, and remain realistic about the resources available.

Join us at Parallel Session 6b, Lean Editorial: Doing More with Less Across Peer Review and Editorial Operations on Thursday 10 September, 11:20–12:05, Deansgate Suite 3.

This is a repost of an article written by The Editorial Hub and published on the ALPSP blog on 20th July 2026.

Reviewer fatigue? Or an engagement problem waiting to be solved?

The narrative around the pressures facing peer review will be familiar to most people working in this space. Submission volumes continue to rise, reviewers are under increasing pressure, and both “reviewer scarcity” and “reviewer fatigue” have become almost shorthand for the challenges the system is facing. As more submissions enter the system, more reviewer invitations inevitably follow – but with fewer people seeming to accept them, there’s a growing sense that peer review is becoming harder to sustain.

It’s perhaps not surprising, then, that the instinctive response is to look for ways to expand the reviewer pool. More submissions must mean a need for more reviewers.

But reading Silverchair’s latest report on the future of peer review reinforces something we’ve been seeing in practice for some time. While reviewer demand is clearly increasing, the report shows that the reviewer pool itself is also growing – and yet it’s becoming harder, not easier, to secure reviews. That raises an obvious question: is this really a question of capacity, or is something else at play?

 

A question of engagement, not just capacity

What this points to, in our view – and what the Silverchair data brings into focus – is a subtle but important shift in how the problem is framed. Rather than thinking primarily about how many reviewers are available, it may be more useful to think about how effectively those reviewers are being engaged.

That certainly aligns with what we see in practice. Working across hundreds of journals each year, and having been involved in peer review management for well over a decade, our experience is not that reviewers are unwilling to review – but that they are increasingly selective. Whether they accept an invitation often comes down to quite practical considerations: whether they recognise the journal or editor, whether the paper feels relevant to their work, whether the invitation is clear, and whether the overall process feels straightforward and worthwhile alongside other demands on their time.

These are all fairly “human” factors, and they don’t always show up clearly in data – but they have a very real impact on outcomes.

 

Why simply finding more reviewers doesn’t always help

If the challenge is framed as a shortage, the response follows quite naturally: expand the database, send more invitations and continue searching for additional reviewers. In practice, though, that doesn’t always solve the problem. Increasing invitation volumes can just as easily lead to more non-responses or declines, which in turn creates additional work for editors without necessarily improving turnaround times. Similarly, expanding reviewer databases without maintaining them can create the appearance of capacity, without actually making it any easier to find engaged, responsive reviewers when they’re needed.
What this highlights is that scale alone isn’t the limiting factor.

 

What makes the difference in practice

What does tend to make a difference is something a little less visible: how well reviewer communities are maintained, understood and engaged with over time. In practice, that often comes down to relatively straightforward things – but they need to be applied consistently:

  • Keeping reviewer databases active and meaningful, rather than simply large.
  • Taking a more considered approach to how invitations are framed and sent.
  • Keeping front of mind that reviewers are giving their time voluntarily, and making sure that experience feels worthwhile.
  • And, importantly, looking beyond the same established networks to engage new and often underutilised communities.

None of this is especially new (it reflects approaches we’ve been applying in practice for many years), but as pressure on the system increases, those details start to matter more.

 

The role of editorial processes

It’s also worth recognising that engagement doesn’t happen in isolation. It is shaped by the editorial processes that sit behind it: how reviewers are selected; how invitation workflows are set up; how databases are managed and maintained; and how editors are supported in navigating all of this. When those processes are working well, engagement tends to follow more naturally. When they are not, even a well-populated reviewer pool can become surprisingly difficult to access. That’s why improving peer review outcomes so often comes down to refining existing workflows and practices, rather than introducing something entirely new.

 

Moving beyond the fatigue narrative

“Reviewer fatigue” remains a useful way of describing the pressures many people are experiencing, and there’s no doubt that those pressures are real. But fatigue alone doesn’t fully explain what we’re seeing. Reviewers are making choices about where they invest their time, and those choices are influenced by context, clarity and connection – often in quite subtle ways. Recognising that doesn’t remove the challenge, but it does shift the focus slightly. Instead of asking how to find more reviewers, the question becomes how to better engage the ones already in the system – and those who perhaps haven’t been reached yet.

 

A subtle but important shift

Peer review is clearly under strain, but it isn’t simply running out of reviewers. What we’re seeing feels more like an engagement challenge than a capacity one.

It’s a subtle distinction, but an important one – particularly for how journals, editors, societies and publishers respond over time. It points to a shift in emphasis, from continually expanding reviewer pools to something we’ve long focused on in practice – how reviewer communities are built, maintained and engaged.

If you’re thinking about how to improve reviewer engagement on your journals, you’re very welcome to contact us.

Proud to Support ALPSP as Silver Sponsor at the 2026 Annual Conference

We’re delighted to share that The Editorial Hub is a Silver Sponsor of the ALPSP Annual Conference and Awards 2026, taking place from 9-11 September in Manchester.

The ALPSP Annual Conference is a cornerstone event for scholarly and professional publishing, bringing together publishers, societies, service providers and industry partners from across the global community. As long‑standing supporters of collaboration, integrity and innovation in editorial workflows, becoming a Silver Sponsor felt like a natural step for us.

ALPSP plays an important role in strengthening and advocating for not‑for‑profit scholarly publishing, while bringing together a broad international community of society, university and commercial publishers, alongside the service providers that support them. With more than 320 member organisations across 35 countries, the conference offers a rare opportunity to step back from day‑to‑day operations and engage in meaningful conversations about what publishing needs next – whether that’s navigating technological change, improving peer review health, or responding to evolving community expectations.

At The Editorial Hub, we work closely with journals and publishers to support robust, scalable editorial and peer review processes. Our presence at ALPSP reflects our commitment not just to the tools and systems that underpin publishing, but to the people, partnerships and shared standards that make the ecosystem work.

As Silver Sponsor, we’re pleased to be supporting an event that values thoughtful discussion, practical insight and collective progress across the industry. We’re particularly looking forward to the conversations that emerge when publishers, societies and service providers come together to reflect honestly on shared challenges – and to explore what genuinely sustainable solutions look like.

If you’re attending the conference in Manchester this September, we’d love to see you there and connect in person. Whether you’re thinking about editorial workflow efficiency, peer review resilience or future‑proofing journal operations, we always welcome the chance to exchange ideas and learn from others in the community. And if you’d like to start a conversation ahead of the conference, you’re very welcome to get in touch at any time – we’re always happy to talk through editorial challenges, share perspectives, or simply compare notes on what’s changing across the scholarly publishing landscape.

We’re delighted to continue supporting ALPSP and to be an active part of what promises to be an engaging and thought‑provoking conference.