Reviewer fatigue? Or an engagement problem waiting to be solved?

May 28, 2026 | Scholarly publishing

The narrative around the pressures facing peer review will be familiar to most people working in this space. Submission volumes continue to rise, reviewers are under increasing pressure, and both “reviewer scarcity” and “reviewer fatigue” have become almost shorthand for the challenges the system is facing. As more submissions enter the system, more reviewer invitations inevitably follow – but with fewer people seeming to accept them, there’s a growing sense that peer review is becoming harder to sustain.

It’s perhaps not surprising, then, that the instinctive response is to look for ways to expand the reviewer pool. More submissions must mean a need for more reviewers.

But reading Silverchair’s latest report on the future of peer review reinforces something we’ve been seeing in practice for some time. While reviewer demand is clearly increasing, the report shows that the reviewer pool itself is also growing – and yet it’s becoming harder, not easier, to secure reviews. That raises an obvious question: is this really a question of capacity, or is something else at play?

 

A question of engagement, not just capacity

What this points to, in our view – and what the Silverchair data brings into focus – is a subtle but important shift in how the problem is framed. Rather than thinking primarily about how many reviewers are available, it may be more useful to think about how effectively those reviewers are being engaged.

That certainly aligns with what we see in practice. Working across hundreds of journals each year, and having been involved in peer review management for well over a decade, our experience is not that reviewers are unwilling to review – but that they are increasingly selective. Whether they accept an invitation often comes down to quite practical considerations: whether they recognise the journal or editor, whether the paper feels relevant to their work, whether the invitation is clear, and whether the overall process feels straightforward and worthwhile alongside other demands on their time.

These are all fairly “human” factors, and they don’t always show up clearly in data – but they have a very real impact on outcomes.

 

Why simply finding more reviewers doesn’t always help

If the challenge is framed as a shortage, the response follows quite naturally: expand the database, send more invitations and continue searching for additional reviewers. In practice, though, that doesn’t always solve the problem. Increasing invitation volumes can just as easily lead to more non-responses or declines, which in turn creates additional work for editors without necessarily improving turnaround times. Similarly, expanding reviewer databases without maintaining them can create the appearance of capacity, without actually making it any easier to find engaged, responsive reviewers when they’re needed.
What this highlights is that scale alone isn’t the limiting factor.

 

What makes the difference in practice

What does tend to make a difference is something a little less visible: how well reviewer communities are maintained, understood and engaged with over time. In practice, that often comes down to relatively straightforward things – but they need to be applied consistently:

  • Keeping reviewer databases active and meaningful, rather than simply large.
  • Taking a more considered approach to how invitations are framed and sent.
  • Keeping front of mind that reviewers are giving their time voluntarily, and making sure that experience feels worthwhile.
  • And, importantly, looking beyond the same established networks to engage new and often underutilised communities.

None of this is especially new (it reflects approaches we’ve been applying in practice for many years), but as pressure on the system increases, those details start to matter more.

 

The role of editorial processes

It’s also worth recognising that engagement doesn’t happen in isolation. It is shaped by the editorial processes that sit behind it: how reviewers are selected; how invitation workflows are set up; how databases are managed and maintained; and how editors are supported in navigating all of this. When those processes are working well, engagement tends to follow more naturally. When they are not, even a well-populated reviewer pool can become surprisingly difficult to access. That’s why improving peer review outcomes so often comes down to refining existing workflows and practices, rather than introducing something entirely new.

 

Moving beyond the fatigue narrative

“Reviewer fatigue” remains a useful way of describing the pressures many people are experiencing, and there’s no doubt that those pressures are real. But fatigue alone doesn’t fully explain what we’re seeing. Reviewers are making choices about where they invest their time, and those choices are influenced by context, clarity and connection – often in quite subtle ways. Recognising that doesn’t remove the challenge, but it does shift the focus slightly. Instead of asking how to find more reviewers, the question becomes how to better engage the ones already in the system – and those who perhaps haven’t been reached yet.

 

A subtle but important shift

Peer review is clearly under strain, but it isn’t simply running out of reviewers. What we’re seeing feels more like an engagement challenge than a capacity one.

It’s a subtle distinction, but an important one – particularly for how journals, editors, societies and publishers respond over time. It points to a shift in emphasis, from continually expanding reviewer pools to something we’ve long focused on in practice – how reviewer communities are built, maintained and engaged.

If you’re thinking about how to improve reviewer engagement on your journals, you’re very welcome to contact us.