Journal Systems, Reporting & Workflow

Make journal operations easier to see, manage and improve

Journal systems should support good editorial work – not create more manual effort, unclear ownership or invisible queues.​

​

The Editorial Hub helps publishers, societies and journal teams understand how their systems, reporting and workflows are working in practice. We identify where friction is building, where visibility is limited, and where carefully chosen changes could make journals easier to manage.​

​

Our approach is practical and independent. We do not sell proprietary platforms or recommend technology for its own sake. We focus on the tools, reporting and workflow changes that will genuinely help your editors, authors, reviewers and operational teams.​

Talk to us about your reviewer workflows

Systems should support the way your journal actually works​​

A submission system is only part of the operating model.​

Templates, reminders, permissions, queues, workflow statuses, reporting outputs and manual workarounds all affect how easily a journal can be run. They shape what editors see, what the editorial office must chase, how risks are identified and how confidently a publisher can monitor performance.​

We work at the point where systems meet real editorial practice: helping teams use the functionality available to them in ways that support clear, manageable and accountable journal operations.​

 

Practical systems expertise​​

We have extensive experience working in most major journal submission systems, including proprietary publisher platforms. Our expertise includes – but is not limited to – ScholarOne, Editorial Manager, eJournalPress, OJS and most major journal submission systems.​

​Our role is not limited to processing manuscripts within a platform. We can help clients assess how workflows, user roles, templates, reminders, reporting and handovers are affecting day-to-day delivery.​

This may include:​

  • Reviewing workflow stages, queues and manuscript-status logic​
  • Assessing templates, reminders and routine correspondence​
  • Identifying unnecessary manual workarounds​
  • Reviewing user roles, permissions and points of handover​
  • Supporting reporting requirements and data interpretation​
  • Helping define requirements for system changes or configuration updates​
  • Coordinating with publishers, system owners or other stakeholders where change requires wider approval​

We work within the permissions, platform configurations and governance arrangements that apply to each journal.

The aim is not change for its own sake, but a system that gives the right people clearer information and fewer avoidable problems.​

Reporting that supports action​

Reporting should tell you what needs attention, not simply describe what has already happened.​

We help clients develop reporting that gives journal leaders a practical view of workload, turnaround, reviewer activity, bottlenecks, overdue actions and emerging risks.​

  • Depending on the journal and system, this may include:​
  • Submission, decision and pipeline activity​
  • Time in workflow status and turnaround trends​
  • Reviewer invitation, acceptance and completion activity​
  • Editor handling and outstanding actions​
  • Transfer flows between journals​
  • Research integrity, appeals or exception-case tracking​
  • Risks, actions and recommended improvements​

The value is not just in producing a report. It is in turning operational information into clear next steps: what needs resolving within the editorial office, what needs editorial input, and what may require a workflow or resourcing change.​

Find friction. Improve what matters

Organic workflow drift

Many workflow problems are not caused by one major failure. They build gradually through unclear responsibilities, duplicated checks, manual tracking, inconsistent templates or work that sits outside the submission system​

Process documentation

We can map the way a journal operates in practice, including the formal workflow and the informal workarounds that have developed around it.​​

Find the improvements that matter

From there, we help clients make proportionate improvements. This might mean clarifying who owns a task, simplifying a handover, adjusting a reminder process, improving a report, documenting a procedure or identifying where a system setting could reduce repetitive effort.​

No fixed model

We do not force journals into a fixed model. We preserve the journal-specific practices and editor preferences that matter, while making the underlying operation clearer and more consistent.​

Tools where they help. People remain accountable

Automation and AI can reduce repetitive effort, improve visibility and help teams focus attention where it is needed.​

They are not a substitute for editorial judgement, operational knowledge or accountable human oversight. ​

The Editorial Hub is tool-agnostic. We do not have a product agenda or a proprietary platform to sell. We help clients assess whether a tool, automation or workflow change will genuinely improve the work: whether it fits the journal’s policies, reduces manual burden, creates false positives, requires disproportionate staff interpretation, or risks making a process harder to manage.​

Where tools are used, experienced people remain responsible for interpreting outputs, documenting concerns and deciding when an issue needs escalation.​

 

Better visibility for research integrity and operational risk​

Systems, reporting and research integrity are closely connected.​

A well-designed workflow makes it easier to identify overdue actions, unusual patterns, repeated delays, incomplete records and potential risk signals early. It also helps ensure that concerns are documented consistently and passed to the right people with the relevant information attached.​

We support the operational side of research integrity through structured workflows, evidence capture, clear records and proportionate escalation. Formal editorial, ethical or scientific decisions remain with the client’s designated editorial and publishing leadership.​

Clear records. Calm communication. Appropriate escalation

Sensitive cases become harder to manage when records are incomplete, correspondence sits across multiple inboxes or next steps are unclear.​

We help keep case histories visible and usable by:​

  • Recording relevant information in the agreed journal or publisher system​
  • Maintaining a clear chronology of actions and correspondence​
  • Preparing concise summaries for editorial or publisher review​
  • Coordinating author, editor, reviewer and publisher communications where appropriate​
  • Tracking agreed next steps and escalation points​
  • Supporting consistent documentation across related cases or journal portfolios​
N

The aim is not to create more process. It is to make sure that decisions can be made with the right information in front of the right people.​

Benefit from our expertise

You do not need to outsource your journal to The Editorial Hub to benefit from the experience behind our work.

Our teams support hundreds of thousands of submissions each year, giving us practical insight into how journal systems, workflows, reporting and operational processes behave at scale.

Alongside our managed services, we can provide experienced colleagues for defined workflow consultancy, project delivery or fractional systems and operations support.

We can help scope the problem, shape the approach and deliver the work. Our project leads can work alongside your internal team, transferring knowledge as they go, or take responsibility for a defined piece of work and return with a clear outcome.

There is no fixed project template. We support journals, publishing teams and adjacent scholarly-publishing programmes with everything from workflow reviews and reporting improvements to system changes, data clean-up, new service design and operational problem-solving.

​

If the problem sits somewhere between systems, workflow and journal operations, we’d love to talk it through with you.

​

Practical expertise, applied in delivery​

The strongest systems work is grounded in the realities of live journals: busy editors, uneven reviewer response, evolving policy requirements, changing editorial teams and workflows that cannot simply be paused for redesign.​

“The Editorial Hub’s knowledge of ScholarOne and Editorial Manager makes them super-users, an indispensable skill providing efficient service, pro-actively streamlining and working collaboratively and in communication with our in-house Editors and Publishers.”

Juanita Goossens-Roach
Peer Review Group Manager, Cambridge University Press

 

Looking for clearer reporting, stronger workflows or better use of your journal systems?​​

Whether you need practical support within a live editorial office, a focused systems review or help through a transition, we can help you identify what will make the greatest operational difference.​