Jenny Bright, our Research Integrity Manager, was fortunate to attend a number of webinars and talks during Peer Review Week 2025. Here, she shares her reflections and key takeaways from the discussions.
AI in Peer Review: Challenge or Opportunity?
The key talking point across the week was artificial intelligence (AI), with a primary focus on “Rethinking Peer Review in the AI Era.”
We discussed how AI is reshaping the peer-review process – and while it presents a number of challenges, it’s important not to overlook the opportunities it brings.
The consensus was clear: AI is here to stay. Publishers must tackle it head-on, implementing robust tools and procedures to identify AI use, ensuring publication integrity is maintained and that AI involvement is made transparent to both authors and readers.
Where AI Is Making an Impact
AI is now prevalent in academic publishing in many areas – from AI-generated articles and manipulated images or data, to the use of AI for conducting reviews, and the tools publishers use to detect and combat AI misuse.
As AI tools become increasingly embedded in academic workflows, questions have been raised around ethics, bias and transparency, such as:
-
How can AI enhance reviewer efficiency without compromising integrity?
-
What ethical frameworks should guide AI-assisted peer review?
-
Which aspects of peer review must remain distinctly human?
My Key Takeaways from Peer Review Week
-
AI in peer review should be a support tool, not a replacement.
Experts agreed that while AI can streamline tasks like plagiarism detection, citation checking, and reviewer matching; human judgment and critical analysis remain essential for evaluating novelty and scientific rigour. It was agreed that AI and humans together can produce an effective peer-review process. -
Industry-wide standards are necessary.
Every publisher is currently handling AI differently, without an overarching set of guidelines. There’s a growing need for clear, cross-publisher policies on how AI should be managed and used throughout the peer-review process, with regular monitoring and review as AI evolves. -
Combatting papermills and identifying data/image manipulation.
AI is a positive and invaluable tool to help detect patterns of misconduct, such as AI use, papermill submissions and citation stacking. There are some pioneering tools in development, and used correctly they can identify ethics concerns in a shorter timescale than would be humanly possible, however they must be tested and used responsibly to avoid false positives. -
Reviewer training and support.
Institutions must educate reviewers on AI tools and their limitations to ensure informed and ethical use. -
Preserving trust and transparency.
Across the week, the publishing community emphasised that trust in peer review is fundamentally important, and there must be openness about how decisions are made – especially when AI is involved.
In Summary
The emergence of AI in peer review, and academic publishing more broadly, is both a threat and an opportunity.
The peer review landscape is changing (and will continue to change) as a result of AI development. We must identify the risks, establish robust safeguards at every potential point of AI integration, and harness AI’s ability to detect anomalies and patterns to combat misconduct.
By doing so, we can ensure research and publications remain high-quality, transparent and trustworthy across scholarly publishing.



