Research integrity in practice: beyond the routine
Research integrity is such a broad term. In practice, the work required day-to-day to maintain and uphold it can differ greatly from one project, journal or case to another.
Integrity checks already form part of routine manuscript handling for the hundreds of journals we support at The Editorial Hub; from plagiarism screening to checks for issues such as image manipulation, AI-generated content and potential papermill activity. Alongside this day-to-day work, our dedicated research integrity team undertakes more detailed project and investigative work, which is the main focus of this article.
Our recent research integrity project work has covered a wide range of areas; including detailed journal audits and investigations into suspicious user accounts, as well as editorial board checks, reviewer-quality audits, citation and reference reviews, and authorship-change investigations.
Much of this work involves looking beyond the issue that first prompted a closer look. What appears initially to concern one manuscript, reviewer, editor or account can sometimes form part of a wider pattern of activity warranting investigation.
Following the evidence through the editorial process
A journal audit is a good example of how detailed this can become.
In audits undertaken by our team, we have looked at publication history, author verification, geographic distribution and email patterns, CRediT information, ORCID records, plagiarism, reviewer suitability and the eventual editorial decision. The resulting report can also trace editor assignments, peer-review history and decision history from submission through to final decision.
No single piece of information necessarily tells the story. The value comes from being able to examine the different elements together and identify areas that warrant closer attention.
The same applies to reviewer activity. Our work has included reviewing peer-review reports across revisions to identify instances where reviewers have recommended citations to their own work or repeatedly recommended an author’s work, as well as checking the quality and relevance of reviews and identifying empty reviews.
We’ve also undertaken reference reviews to check validity, monitor self-citation and flag hallucinated references, and investigated authorship changes from submission through revision and publication, including the reasons and evidence provided for those changes.
Sometimes the manuscript isn’t the starting point
Research integrity work isn’t limited to examining content.
Our team also carries out background checks on prospective editorial board members and guest editors. Depending on the requirements of the client, these can include checks of institutional affiliation, publication and editorial history, retractions, professional experience and other relevant information, resulting in a report for the publisher to consider.
Another strand of our work involves users who have already been identified by a client’s ethics team as potentially concerning. As part of that work, we apply the appropriate flags or system-access changes specified by the publisher and search for potentially linked accounts using alternative names or email addresses. Possible matches are then returned to the ethics team for further review.
That distinction matters. Identifying something potentially suspicious isn’t the same as determining that misconduct has occurred. Our role is to investigate the concern, assess and document the available evidence and, where appropriate, make appropriate recommendations based on what we find.
Research integrity can be preventative as well as investigative
A lot of the work above also illustrates why research integrity doesn’t have to start after a serious problem has been identified.
Checking prospective editors and guest editors, monitoring reviewer activity, examining unusual account relationships or reviewing references and authorship changes can all form part of the wider editorial process.
Our current research integrity services therefore extend across submitted and published manuscripts, editor and reviewer due diligence, suspicious-user monitoring, investigations and post-publication support, as well as work on policies, SOPs and editorial processes.
Our practical experience shows how preventative and investigative work can sit alongside one another. Some activity responds to an existing concern; elsewhere, the focus is on identifying and examining risks earlier or strengthening the processes around them.
And what about what’s already been published?
Research integrity questions don’t necessarily end at publication either.
Our recent work has included checks on published articles, including analysing peer-review activity for potential integrity concerns, as well as citation, reference and authorship reviews.
Our post-publication work also includes investigating suspicious accounts and articles, account linking and flagging, and reporting findings back to publisher teams. We are also extending this work into published archive review, investigating concerns that have been flagged and leading the appropriate follow-up where required.
This is an area we think is worth exploring separately in a later post. Strengthening the checks applied to content moving through today’s editorial workflows is one challenge; deciding how to approach potential concerns within an existing body of published research is another.
Where do tools fit?
Technology is part of this work too, but we think it is important to be specific about its role rather than simply saying that AI or automation will solve research-integrity problems.
Our team has hands-on experience with tools covering plagiarism detection, AI-generated or manipulated text, image manipulation and potential paper-mill activity. In our approach, outputs from tools are reviewed and interpreted by trained staff and used to support decision-making rather than make the decision itself.
There is much more to say about what using these tools looks like in practice, including where they are useful, where they need further investigation and what they mean for editorial workflows. We’ll come back to that in a separate post, too.
Connecting research integrity with editorial operations
One of the advantages of combining specialist research integrity expertise with day-to-day editorial office management is the view it gives across different parts of the publishing process.
Jenny Bright, our Research Integrity Manager, leads our specialist research integrity expertise, supported by a dedicated team working on research integrity projects. Alongside this dedicated project work, that expertise feeds into our wider operations. Across the journals and projects we support, our Managing Editors and Editorial Assistants can identify and document potential concerns through their day-to-day work, drawing on specialist guidance where something needs closer examination or escalation.
That can help provide context for activity that might otherwise be considered in isolation: a concern raised during manuscript handling, an unusual reviewer pattern, questions around an account or affiliation, or something identified through a wider audit. Specialist research integrity expertise doesn’t sit apart from editorial operations; it works alongside them.
A practical view of research integrity
Perhaps the clearest lesson from the range of work our team is doing is the importance of context. A concern rarely exists entirely in isolation, and understanding what sits around it can be just as important as identifying the initial issue.
That might mean investigating one suspicious account and then looking for connections with others. It might mean examining a peer-review report, checking a reference list, carrying out due diligence on a potential editor, or tracing the complete editorial history of a manuscript.
Sometimes the work is preventative. Sometimes it responds to an existing concern. And sometimes it means going back to content that has already been published.
What matters is being able to bring those different pieces of evidence together, understand them in their editorial context, and recognise when something warrants further investigation or escalation.
For The Editorial Hub, that practical, connected approach is increasingly an important part of how we support publishers with research integrity and publishing ethics.



