In scholarly publishing, trust isn’t optional – it’s everything. Every paper, every review and every editorial decision contributes to the credibility of the research record. At The Editorial Hub, research integrity isn’t just a policy; it’s embedded in everything we do, from the first submission check to the final decision. Here’s how we help publishers, societies and editors safeguard quality, reduce risks and maintain confidence in every stage of peer review.
Why Research Integrity Matters
Research integrity is fundamental to the credibility and reliability of published research and scholarly content. It underpins the trust that publishers, societies and editorial offices place in the work they publish. When integrity is upheld, research can be assessed, built upon and relied on with confidence. When it is compromised, the impact extends across journals, communities and reputations.
For editorial offices, research integrity is not an abstract principle. It is embedded in everyday editorial work, including managing submissions, supporting peer review, applying ethical and editorial policies, and maintaining accurate records of editorial decisions. As submission volumes grow and editorial workflows become more complex, consistency and transparency across these processes are increasingly important.
Publishers and societies are responsible for defining editorial and ethical policies, often informed by recognised industry guidance such as that provided by COPE. The Editorial Hub supports publishers by implementing these policies within editorial workflows, helping to ensure they are applied consistently and in line with client expectations. This support plays an important and vital role in identifying potential concerns early and ensuring they are handled appropriately.
The Editorial Hub as a First Line of Defence
We see ourselves as a critical first line of defence for research integrity. Our team combines deep expertise in manuscript assessment, preliminary checks and peer-review management to identify risks such as papermills, peer-review manipulation, plagiarism, image/data issues and ethical non-compliance early in the process. By surfacing concerns before peer review begins, we allow reviewers to focus on scientific merit, improving both efficiency and reliability of the editorial process while reducing the burden on reviewers.
At The Editorial Hub, research integrity is reinforced through close alignment with publisher and society policies and through well-defined editorial processes. Our work is shaped by our clients’ requirements, ensuring that expectations around ethics, authorship, conflicts of interest and transparency are reflected accurately throughout the editorial processes we undertake. Applying these standards consistently is essential to maintaining confidence in editorial outcomes.
Research Integrity Leadership
Our Research Integrity Manager (Jenny Bright) leads our work to uphold the highest ethical standards in scholarly publishing. This role includes developing processes and assessing tools to detect issues such as plagiarism, image manipulation, papermills and peer-review manipulation, as well as providing guidance and resources to our team, editors and clients on best practice. Jenny represents us in wider industry discussions, sharing insights and contributing to evolving best practices that maintain trust and credibility in peer review.
Clear collaboration and communication are central to this approach. Our editorial offices work closely with journal editors and publisher contacts to support informed decision-making. Maintaining clear and open lines of communication, accurate documentation and shared understanding of responsibilities helps ensure that issues are addressed efficiently and in accordance with agreed policies.
Supporting Editors and Reviewers
Peer review remains a key component for maintaining quality and credibility. Through structured editorial support, our team manages peer review workflows that are fair, transparent and well documented. This supports editors in coordinating reviews, recording decisions and maintaining clear oversight of the review process. We also provide structured reviewer support, including templates and integrity checklists, helping reviewers systematically identify potential issues and improve the consistency and quality of peer-review reports.
Tools, Automation and AI Oversight
The increasing use of artificial intelligence across research and publishing introduces additional considerations for research integrity. Expectations around the use of AI tools in submissions, peer review and editorial processes continue to evolve. We actively review the landscape of AI and research integrity tools, trial and test emerging technologies, and advise clients on those best suited to their journals and workflows. By combining automation with human oversight, these tools allow us to detect potential concerns early and reduce reviewer burden while maintaining robust editorial judgement.
Maintaining the Research Record
Maintaining the integrity of the research record is an ongoing responsibility. It requires sustained collaboration between publishers, societies and editorial support providers, as well as the flexibility to adapt processes as standards, technologies and expectations develop.
At The Editorial Hub, we see research integrity as a shared commitment and collaboration with the clients we support. By working in line with publisher policies, communicating effectively with editorial stakeholders and applying consistent editorial practices, we help publishers and societies proudly maintain confidence in their editorial processes and the content they publish.
Shaping Research Integrity Standards
Through our active industry engagement, including membership in COPE, ALPSP and STM, as well as participation in seminars and events, we contribute to shaping best practice in research integrity and ensure our team remains at the forefront of evolving standards.
Hannah Gardiner, Managing Editor / Social Media Manager



