Research Integrity & Publication Ethics
Human-led research integrity support for real editorial workflows.Research integrity work is not simply about spotting a potential issue.
It is about knowing what information to capture, how to document it clearly, when to seek further input and how to escalate concerns without creating unnecessary work or alarm for editors or staff.
The Editorial Hub supports publishers, societies and journal teams with practical, human-led research integrity and publication ethics workflows. We help teams identify, document, coordinate and escalate potential concerns appropriately, while keeping formal editorial, publisher and institutional decisions with the people responsible for making them.
Support without overstepping
The Editorial Hub does not determine misconduct, impose sanctions or replace editorial, publisher or institutional judgement.
Our role is to support the operational work around a concern: gathering and recording relevant information, checking that the right questions have been asked, maintaining a clear case history, coordinating communications and helping ensure that concerns reach the right people with an accurate summary of the available evidence.
This gives editors and publishers a more complete basis for decision-making, without blurring roles or responsibilities.
Identify. Document. Escalate.
Research integrity concerns often emerge within ordinary editorial workflows: during submission checks, reviewer invitations, revisions, author queries, appeals or production handover.
Our teams are trained to recognise potential signals, document what they have observed and follow agreed escalation routes. Borderline or more complex concerns can be reviewed with specialist research integrity support before onward escalation.
Our approach is designed to be proportionate.
Not every anomaly requires the same response. We help clients distinguish between routine clarification, further information gathering and concerns that should be escalated to editorial leadership, the publisher or another agreed authority.
Support at the points where concerns arise
Submission and initial screening:
We can support agreed checks around similarity reports, author and affiliation information, declarations, permissions, ethics statements, data availability, image or file concerns, and other journal-specific requirements.
Potential issues are recorded clearly and flagged for editorial or publisher consideration where appropriate.
Peer review and reviewer workflows:
Research integrity can also arise through reviewer activity. We can help identify and document unusual reviewer behaviour, possible conflicts, concerns around reviewer identity, suspicious recommendation patterns or incomplete reviewer records.
Final decisions about reviewer suitability and action remain with the journal’s designated editorial leadership.
Appeals and suspected misconduct reports workflows:
Editorial decision appeals and reports of suspected misconduct are two workflows that require meticulous coordination, including validation of presented facts, and collation of relevant records.
We support correspondence, documentation, workflow tracking and curation of relevant materials so that editors and publishers review a clear account of what has been received, considered and communicated.
Post-acceptance and production queries:
Concerns can arise after editorial acceptance as well as before it. We can help ensure that issues are recorded, routed and followed up appropriately when they involve author queries, corrections, permissions, files or other publication-risk matters.
Editorial and reviewer background checks:
We assist publishers in evaluating new and existing editorial board members, guest editors and peer reviewers through structured due-diligence assessments.
These checks help publishers reduce exposure to fraudulent editorial activity and reputational harm.
Paper mill signal identification:
We provide proactive monitoring and investigative support to identify potentially suspicious submission and peer review activity, enabling teams to make informed and policy-compliant decisions quickly.
Our specialists can identify signals of potential paper mill activity such as coordinated submissions, duplicate submissions, suspicious account creation, network anomalies, rapid review cycles, and problematic identities.
Tools where they help.
People remain accountable.
Tools can really help teams to identify possible misconduct signals. However, they cannot determine context, intent or the appropriate editorial response.
The Editorial Hub is tool-agnostic. We do not promote a proprietary technology stack or treat a tool output as a decision.
Instead, we help clients use tools proportionately: considering what they identify, the time required for staff interpretation, their fit with journal policy, the level of false-positive burden they create, and whether they genuinely improve the workflow.
Experienced people remain responsible for interpreting information, documenting potential concerns and deciding when an issue needs escalation.
Integrity support that connects with live journal operations
Research integrity cannot sit separately from editorial office delivery.
Submission checks, reviewer workflows, system records, reporting, editor communication and escalation routes all influence how effectively a journal identifies and handles potential concerns.
The Editorial Hub can help clients to connect these elements: improving risk visibility in everyday workflows, identifying where records are weak or handovers introduce avoidable risk, and making escalation routes clearer for editors and editorial office staff.
The right level of support for your journal
Embedded support: As part of an ongoing editorial-office service, we can support agreed screening, documentation, workflow coordination and escalation processes within the journal’s established policies and roles.
Case support: For a specific concern or complex group of cases, we can provide structured operational support: helping gather information, maintain records, coordinate communications and prepare materials for review by the responsible editorial or publisher team.
Process review, training and tools review: For clients looking to strengthen their approach, we can scope separate work such as:
- Research integrity workflow reviews Documentation and escalation audits
- Training for editorial-office staff, editors or boards Integrity tool or process review
- Reporting and trend-analysis support
- Development of practical case-handling procedures
All project work is agreed in advance, with clear objectives, responsibilities and boundaries.
Built for sensitive, high-accountability workflows
Led by Jenny Bright, Research Integrity Manager
Jenny Bright leads The Editorial Hub’s research integrity capability, helping journals turn policy expectations into practical checks, records and escalation routes.
Her recent work includes co-authoring a Scientific Data paper on the Editorial Reference Handbook and contributing to the Data & Policy pilot embedding reproducibility and FAIR data checks into editorial workflows.
Through active engagement with COPE, ALPSP, STM and wider industry discussions, Jenny helps ensure our team’s approach remains informed by evolving best practice in research integrity.
Support that knows where editorial judgement belongs
“They have been scrupulous about ensuring that they do not bother us about routine matters that can be dealt with in a standard way, whereas they do always consult us about matters that require our input.”
Adrian Moore & Lucy O’Brien, Co-Editors, MIND (OUP)
“Her attention to detail has pre-empted potentially troubling situations.”
Dr Shireen Hassim, Social Politics (OUP)
Looking for practical research integrity support that strengthens your editorial workflow?
Whether you need embedded support, help with a specific concern, staff training or a review of your current processes, we can help you identify the right next step.
Explore our capabilities



